Wsrtjtyk

I'm seeing several devices trying to connect to an AP (using wireshark), several send and receive the "Probe response" message (802.11)


But the don't even send the association request.
Why is that? does the connection considered to be closed or open only after the probe response?

How did they know not to sent the association request?
Here is a response packet of a device that didn't sent a association request afterwords

Frame 442: 243 bytes on wire (1944 bits), 243 bytes captured (1944 bits) on interface 0

    Interface id: 0 (\.airpcap00)

    Encapsulation type: IEEE 802.11 plus radiotap radio header (23)

    Arrival Time: Mar 18, 2014 21:32:31.171606000 Jerusalem Standard Time

    [Time shift for this packet: 0.000000000 seconds]

    Epoch Time: 1395171151.171606000 seconds

    [Time delta from previous captured frame: 0.002142000 seconds]

    [Time delta from previous displayed frame: 0.096003000 seconds]

    [Time since reference or first frame: 13.290039000 seconds]

    Frame Number: 442

    Frame Length: 243 bytes (1944 bits)

    Capture Length: 243 bytes (1944 bits)

    [Frame is marked: False]

    [Frame is ignored: False]

    [Protocols in frame: radiotap:wlan_radio:wlan]

Radiotap Header v0, Length 20

    Header revision: 0

    Header pad: 0

    Header length: 20

    Present flags

        Present flags word: 0x000018ee

    Flags: 0x10

        .... ...0 = CFP: False

        .... ..0. = Preamble: Long

        .... .0.. = WEP: False

        .... 0... = Fragmentation: False

        ...1 .... = FCS at end: True

        ..0. .... = Data Pad: False

        .0.. .... = Bad FCS: False

        0... .... = Short GI: False

    Data Rate: 1.0 Mb/s

    Channel frequency: 2412 [BG 1]

    Channel flags: 0x00a0, Complementary Code Keying (CCK), 2 GHz spectrum

    Antenna signal: -70dBm

    Antenna noise: -100dBm

    Signal Quality: 76

    Antenna: 0

    dB antenna signal: 30dB

802.11 radio information

    PHY type: 802.11b (4)

    Short preamble: False

    Data rate: 1.0 Mb/s

    Channel: 1

    Frequency: 2412MHz

    Signal strength (dBm): -70dBm

    Noise level (dBm): -100dBm

    [Duration: 1976µs]

IEEE 802.11 Probe Response, Flags: ........C

    Type/Subtype: Probe Response (0x0005)

    Frame Control Field: 0x5000

        .... ..00 = Version: 0

        .... 00.. = Type: Management frame (0)

        0101 .... = Subtype: 5

        Flags: 0x00

    .000 0001 0011 1010 = Duration: 314 microseconds

    Receiver address: SamsungE_74:b9:f9 (d0:22:be:74:b9:f9)

    Destination address: SamsungE_74:b9:f9 (d0:22:be:74:b9:f9)

    Transmitter address: Sagemcom_fb:5d:9d (00:78:9e:fb:5d:9d)

    Source address: Sagemcom_fb:5d:9d (00:78:9e:fb:5d:9d)

    BSS Id: Sagemcom_fb:5d:9d (00:78:9e:fb:5d:9d)

    .... .... .... 0000 = Fragment number: 0

    0010 1000 0011 .... = Sequence number: 643

    Frame check sequence: 0xeb99cc98 [correct]

    [FCS Status: Good]

IEEE 802.11 wireless LAN

    Fixed parameters (12 bytes)

        Timestamp: 0x0000008df2ce0b90

        Beacon Interval: 0.102400 [Seconds]

        Capabilities Information: 0x0411

            .... .... .... ...1 = ESS capabilities: Transmitter is an AP

            .... .... .... ..0. = IBSS status: Transmitter belongs to a BSS

            .... ..0. .... 00.. = CFP participation capabilities: No point coordinator at AP (0x00)

            .... .... ...1 .... = Privacy: AP/STA can support WEP

            .... .... ..0. .... = Short Preamble: Not Allowed

            .... .... .0.. .... = PBCC: Not Allowed

            .... .... 0... .... = Channel Agility: Not in use

            .... ...0 .... .... = Spectrum Management: Not Implemented

            .... .1.. .... .... = Short Slot Time: In use

            .... 0... .... .... = Automatic Power Save Delivery: Not Implemented

            ...0 .... .... .... = Radio Measurement: Not Implemented

            ..0. .... .... .... = DSSS-OFDM: Not Allowed

            .0.. .... .... .... = Delayed Block Ack: Not Implemented

            0... .... .... .... = Immediate Block Ack: Not Implemented

    Tagged parameters (183 bytes)

        Tag: SSID parameter set: HOTBOX-9810

            Tag Number: SSID parameter set (0)

            Tag length: 11

            SSID: HOTBOX-9810

        Tag: Supported Rates 1(B), 2(B), 5.5(B), 11(B), 18, 24, 36, 54, [Mbit/sec]

            Tag Number: Supported Rates (1)

            Tag length: 8

            Supported Rates: 1(B) (0x82)

            Supported Rates: 2(B) (0x84)

            Supported Rates: 5.5(B) (0x8b)

            Supported Rates: 11(B) (0x96)

            Supported Rates: 18 (0x24)

            Supported Rates: 24 (0x30)

            Supported Rates: 36 (0x48)

            Supported Rates: 54 (0x6c)

        Tag: DS Parameter set: Current Channel: 1

            Tag Number: DS Parameter set (3)

            Tag length: 1

            Current Channel: 1

        Tag: ERP Information

            Tag Number: ERP Information (42)

            Tag length: 1

            ERP Information: 0x00

        Tag: ERP Information

            Tag Number: ERP Information (47)

            Tag length: 1

            ERP Information: 0x00

        Tag: RSN Information

            Tag Number: RSN Information (48)

            Tag length: 24

            RSN Version: 1

            Group Cipher Suite: 00:0f:ac (Ieee 802.11) TKIP

            Pairwise Cipher Suite Count: 2

            Pairwise Cipher Suite List 00:0f:ac (Ieee 802.11) AES (CCM) 00:0f:ac (Ieee 802.11) TKIP

            Auth Key Management (AKM) Suite Count: 1

            Auth Key Management (AKM) List 00:0f:ac (Ieee 802.11) PSK

            RSN Capabilities: 0x000c

        Tag: Extended Supported Rates 6, 9, 12, 48, [Mbit/sec]

            Tag Number: Extended Supported Rates (50)

            Tag length: 4

            Extended Supported Rates: 6 (0x0c)

            Extended Supported Rates: 9 (0x12)

            Extended Supported Rates: 12 (0x18)

            Extended Supported Rates: 48 (0x60)

        Tag: HT Capabilities (802.11n D1.10)

            Tag Number: HT Capabilities (802.11n D1.10) (45)

            Tag length: 26

            HT Capabilities Info: 0x18fc

            A-MPDU Parameters: 0x1b

            Rx Supported Modulation and Coding Scheme Set: MCS Set

            HT Extended Capabilities: 0x0000

            Transmit Beam Forming (TxBF) Capabilities: 0x00000000

            Antenna Selection (ASEL) Capabilities: 0x00

        Tag: HT Information (802.11n D1.10)

            Tag Number: HT Information (802.11n D1.10) (61)

            Tag length: 22

            Primary Channel: 1

            HT Information Subset (1 of 3): 0x08

            HT Information Subset (2 of 3): 0x0004

            HT Information Subset (3 of 3): 0x0000

            Rx Supported Modulation and Coding Scheme Set: Basic MCS Set

        Tag: Vendor Specific: Broadcom

            Tag Number: Vendor Specific (221)

            Tag length: 9

            OUI: 00:10:18 (Broadcom)

            Vendor Specific OUI Type: 2

            Vendor Specific Data: 0201f02c0000

        Tag: Vendor Specific: Microsoft Corp.: WPA Information Element

            Tag Number: Vendor Specific (221)

            Tag length: 28

            OUI: 00:50:f2 (Microsoft Corp.)

            Vendor Specific OUI Type: 1

            Type: WPA Information Element (0x01)

            WPA Version: 1

            Multicast Cipher Suite: 00:50:f2 (Microsoft Corp.) TKIP

            Unicast Cipher Suite Count: 2

            Unicast Cipher Suite List 00:50:f2 (Microsoft Corp.) AES (CCM) 00:50:f2 (Microsoft Corp.) TKIP

            Auth Key Management (AKM) Suite Count: 1

            Auth Key Management (AKM) List 00:50:f2 (Microsoft Corp.) PSK

        Tag: Vendor Specific: Microsoft Corp.: WMM/WME: Parameter Element

            Tag Number: Vendor Specific (221)

            Tag length: 24

            OUI: 00:50:f2 (Microsoft Corp.)

            Vendor Specific OUI Type: 2

            Type: WMM/WME (0x02)

            WME Subtype: Parameter Element (1)

            WME Version: 1

            WME QoS Info: 0x80

            Reserved: 00

            Ac Parameters ACI 0 (Best Effort), ACM no, AIFSN 3, ECWmin/max 4/10 (CWmin/max 15/1023), TXOP 0

            Ac Parameters ACI 1 (Background), ACM no, AIFSN 7, ECWmin/max 4/10 (CWmin/max 15/1023), TXOP 0

            Ac Parameters ACI 2 (Video), ACM no, AIFSN 2, ECWmin/max 3/4 (CWmin/max 7/15), TXOP 94

            Ac Parameters ACI 3 (Voice), ACM no, AIFSN 2, ECWmin/max 2/3 (CWmin/max 3/7), TXOP 47

These devices are simply looking for available networks, not trying to associate with them. This is normal behavior for a device looking for networks and to determine what the AP capabilities are.

The device won't send an association request until you tell it to connect to that network.

But the don't even send the association request. Why is that? does the connection considered to be closed or open only after the probe response?
How did they know not to sent the association request?

They are simply checking the availability of wireless networks around them. This does not necessarily indicate they actually want to join or associate to the network.

When a wireless client is looking to join a wireless network (or check for the possibility of roaming to a new one), they send out probe requests. Often these are general in nature and how a device discovers which networks are around them. Think of it as the client device yelling, "Can any wireless networks hear me?"

Probe requests can also be directed to particular networks. "Can network ABCXYZ hear me?" This is required with the SSID is "hidden" and is the default way many mobile devices try to reconnect to stored networks.

When an access point hears a probe request, if the probe request is either general in nature or for the configured wireless network, it responds with a probe response. This behavior is defined by the IEEE standards for 802.11 networks. So your AP will always respond to any general probe request from a wireless client.

You have likely experienced this yourself without realizing it. When you want to join a wireless device to a network, you have likely been presented with a list of wireless networks and selected the one you wanted to join. This list was generated largely from the probe responses the wireless client received from APs in the area when it sent out probe requests.

All APs also advertise themselves with beacon frames periodically, which is the other way that clients can find wireless networks in the area. However this is a slower process for discovery, so the vast majority of clients use probe request/responses primarily for discovery.